Blog Layout

Why you need to gather social proof to increase conversions

Lisa East • Oct 07, 2022

Why you need to gather social proof to increase conversions

We’ve all been there… asking a customer for a review and hearing crickets. Although it’s hard to gather social proof for your business, it’s an essential task. Here’s our guide to making it easier to get compelling reviews from your happy customers to boost conversions. 

Why is getting social proof so important?

Social proof is an effective marketing tactic for many reasons. It helps you to – 

  • Build credibility and trust
  • Increase brand awareness 
  • Convert leads into customers 


Let’s put ourselves into the customer’s shoes. Would you rather buy the product with 200+ positive reviews, or the one with only three?


As a new customer, it’s beneficial to see what other customers have said about the product/service before buying. The classic know, like, and trust element is sped up when you gather social proof.


Social proof and the bandwagon effect 

You know when you see someone else with something, and it makes you want it? Or when you see a crowd of people following each other without understanding why? 


That’s the bandwagon effect. It’s a cognitive bias that often makes humans follow each other’s behaviour. People can be seen to ignore their own beliefs, which can also be known as herd mentality. 


As consumers, we don’t want to miss out on the best option available to us. That’s why we want things more after hearing great reviews from others.


The bandwagon effect highlights the importance of why you should gather social proof. If your brand is seen to be taking the lead in the industry with lots of happy customers, others will follow more easily. 


How to successfully gather social proof from customers 

There are lots of ways you can ask your past clients for reviews or testimonials. The approach you take to gather social proof will depend on the type of business you run and the customers you serve. 


Use an online review platform to gather reviews in one place. Popular options include – 

  • Google (on your business profile on Google Maps)
  • LinkedIn recommendations 
  • Amazon product reviews 
  • Survey Monkey 
  • Which?
  • Trustpilot 
  • Feefo 


A few of the above come with a cost, and as a small business owner you may prefer to collate your reviews, testimonials and endorsements using the free resources you have for now. Like Google reviews which also helps you with your SEO and LinkedIn, which helps you increase your credability.


Below is an informative video showing you how to ask for a LinkedIn endorsement.


Here are our suggestions about how to ask for a review using different methods. 


Manual follow-up 


For some businesses, sending a manual follow-up email with a link to your chosen review platform will work best. If you’ve had a close relationship with your customer, you can add in personal notes about how much you’ve enjoyed working together. 


Generally, people want to support you if they’ve been happy with your service. Mention how important reviews are to growing your business in your email. 


Pick up the phone 


Although some people find asking for help on the phone scary, plucking up the courage can be a great way to get people on board with leaving a review. 


You can also ask if they’d be willing to talk about their experience with your brand for a case study. Not every person will be comfortable doing so, but you don’t know until you ask! 


Ask for a LinkedIn recommendation


If you use LinkedIn as part of your marketing strategy, asking for a LinkedIn recommendation can be a great way to gather social proof on a platform you’re active on. 


Having recommendations on your profile will build credibility when you’re connecting with new potential customers and growing your audience. View the video above to find out how to request LinkedIn recommendation.


Use automated software 


Platforms like Feefo and Trustpilot offer automations to gather social proof from your customers without you having to do anything. They can access details from online booking requests and digital receipts to send SMS or email messages asking for a review. 


Although less personal, it can work for companies that have lots of customers and would otherwise find it difficult to gather social proof. 


Printed requests in packaging


For some businesses, you might find adding in a printed review request into your customer parcels a great way to gather social proof. Add in a personal note about who’s packed the order and ask to leave a review. 


User-generated content 

UGC video creation

With any of the methods, you can encourage people to create user-generated content and share it to their socials with gifted products. This is a great cost-effective way to encourage people to talk about your brand online. Read more about how to benefit from user-generated content in social media here.


No matter how you ask for them, be sure to include your positive testimonials across all your online touchpoints, including – 

  • All areas of your website  - for example, running along the webpage thats relevant to the review
  • Landing pages
  • Email opt-in pages 
  • Social media posts 
  • Newsletters 
  • On product listings 
  • Email footers
  • LinkedIn profiles
  • Downloads


How to add social proof to your social media strategy 

Now you know how to gather social proof, how do you use it in your social media content? 


Social proof can be a great part of your content strategy, nurturing your audience. It covers one of three types of content – nurture, money, and growth. 


Nurture content helps existing followers to remain loyal but can also solidify your credibility to new customers. It’s all about building trust so people feel more comfortable buying from you. Check out our checklist for successful content for more information. 


You can share the social proof by creating a visual of the review and posting that online. We recommend using Canva to create a branded image, like below. Or if your audience responds well to text-only posts, simply copy and paste your reviews! 

LINGO review

If the testimonial includes lots of detail, pick out the key aspects only. Reviews can often be most impactful when they are short and to the point.


Lastly, if you’ve received great user-generated content with a review as a video or image, share it straight to your feeds. With longer video content, you can even break it down into smaller clips to share. 


That should have given you a great starting point on how to gather social proof to increase conversions. If you need more support with your social media strategy, sign up for our LINGO course or get in touch for bespoke training. 

How you can improve your visual communications in marketing your business
By Lisa East 15 Apr, 2024
On paper, you may well have all the bases covered in terms of providing information and a good experience for your clients, but if your visual communication in marketing isn’t coherent and polished, it can undermine all the positive messaging around your branding and product. Read our article to see where we can help.
Our blog will help one-service brands keep their social media fresh when it starts looking 'samey'
By Lisa East 18 Mar, 2024
To keep your social media marketing fresh for single-service/product brands, you need to understand your audience and address their needs with interactive content. Share customer reviews and behind-the-scenes insights, and engage with industry-related topics and other accounts. At The Thinking Cap, we specialise in refreshing social media strategies tailored to your brand.
Why using customer feedback in marketing is your new superpower
By Lisa East 22 Feb, 2024
Implementing customer feedback not only enhances the customer journey and experience, but in turn will also boost your marketing efforts. Being customer-centric in marketing means prioritising the needs, preferences, and experiences of the people you serve
By Lisa East 06 Feb, 2024
Why your business needs a marketing team with creative flair It’s no secret that most marketing is now done online, and many businesses are looking for an external marketing team to help them to see the wood for the trees when it comes to their online presence. My top recommendation is to find yourself a marketing team with creative flair. 
The Thinking Cap started working with Leeds-based Hemingway Tailors as their social media partners.
By Lisa East 27 Jan, 2024
Read our case study to see how we elevated a simple tailored products into a quirky loveable tongue-in-cheek social media campaign. Which really helped our Leeds-based tailor gain traction and brand awareness and really got people talking about the Hemingway Tailors’ brand'.
We delve into how we became instrumental marketing partners for Holmeshaw Property Investment
By Lisa East 26 Jan, 2024
In the competitive landscape of property investment, Leeds-based Holmeshaw sought to elevate its brand presence and solidify its position in the market. Enter The Thinking Cap, a dynamic marketing agency renowned for its innovative strategies and client-centric approach. This case study delves into how The Thinking Cap became instrumental marketing partners for Holmeshaw, driving transformative results and shaping a new era of success.
Creating effective business social media not just fluff!
By Lisa East 19 Dec, 2023
There are huge opportunities for companies to market themselves to new audiences and play to their strengths using effective business social media accounts
Keeping social media social… to make sure your marketing stands out from the crowd
By Lisa East 14 Nov, 2023
Social media is named social media because of its huge ability to bring people together and bring connection in a fractured world. This means that as well as giving individuals a place to keep in touch with friends and family, social media offers huge opportunities to brands too, who can display their personality and company culture by showing the human side of their company to the world.
How bringing in a marketing team will give your company a fresh perspective
By Lisa East 23 Oct, 2023
Many businesses find it difficult to raise their profile, and growing companies in particular may not consider it a viable option to bring in a marketing team, opting instead to manage their marketing strategy themselves. We’re a husband-wife team with decades of experience in marketing and social media for both small and large businesses across the world, including blue-chip companies such as Barclays and Lloyds, as well as Nike and can help.
9 common content marketing hurdles every business owner faces
By Lisa East 19 Sep, 2023
If you’re coming across some frustrating content marketing hurdles when trying to generate more leads and business, know this: you’re not alone. Almost every business owner will face at least one (but usually more) of these common challenges. Let’s run through what they are – and how to solve them.
More Posts

I hope you enjoyed reading this blog post.

If you’d like further help, let’s jump on a call and have a chat.

Share by: